Key validity bug in GnuPG 1.2.1 and earlier

From: David Shaw (dshawat_private)
Date: Sat May 03 2003 - 18:35:26 PDT

  • Next message: securityat_private: "Security Update: [CSSA-2003-019.0] OpenLinux: tcp SYN with FIN packets are not discarded" 

    As part of the development of GnuPG 1.2.2, a bug was discovered in the
key validation code.  This bug causes keys with more than one user ID
to give all user IDs on the key the amount of validity given to the
most-valid key.

This bug does not impact any key with only one user ID.  Photo IDs
("user attribute IDs") do not count as an additional user ID for the
purposes of this bug.

For example, given a key with two user IDs:
   Alice <aliceat_private>
and
   Alice's other address <aliceat_private>

If the encrypting user has a trust path to to the ID
aliceat_private, then this ID is fully valid, and there is no
warning message when encrypting to aliceat_private

If the encrypting user has either an insufficient or no trust path to
the ID "aliceat_private", then that ID is either not fully
valid, or not valid at all respectively.  There should be a warning
message given when encrypting to this other user ID ("it is not
certain this key belongs to the user named in the user ID / do you
want to encrypt to it anyway?"), but due to the bug, the invalid user
ID is accepted as valid and no warning message is given.

This bug has been fixed in the newly released GnuPG 1.2.2, and
upgrading is the recommended fix for this problem.  For those who
cannot upgrade for whatever reason, the attached patch fixes the
problem as well.  The patch should apply (perhaps with some offsets)
to GnuPG 1.2,1, 1.2.0, or 1.0.7.  Note that GnuPG 1.0.6 (and possibly
earlier) versions have the same problem, but these versions are too
old to successfully apply the patch.  If you are using GnuPG 1.0.6 or
earlier versions, please upgrade.

The GnuPG Team (David, Stefan, Timo and Werner)

    This archive was generated by hypermail 2b30 : Mon May 05 2003 - 09:14:35 PDT