[Politech] Libety Round Table supports exhibitionist webmistress [fs]

From: Declan McCullagh (declan@private)
Date: Mon Jan 26 2004 - 21:11:41 PST

  • Next message: Declan McCullagh: "[Politech] Canadian cops raid reporter's home in probe over leaks [fs]"

    News coverage:
    http://edition.cnn.com/2003/TECH/internet/12/30/offbeat.naked.web.ticket.ap/
    >The 21-year-old Web designer was busted for violating Lincoln's public 
    >nudity ordinance by posting pictures on her Web site that apparently 
    >showed her naked in a downtown bar... (Melissa) Harrington was to be 
    >arraigned in Lancaster County Court on January 29. If convicted, she faces 
    >a maximum penalty of six months in jail and a $500 fine.
    
    Original documents:
    http://www.thesmokinggun.com/archive/nakedlincoln1.html
    
    Melissa's site:
    http://www.melissalincoln.com/main.html
    
    The Liberty Round Table's "Free Melissa" project:
    http://www.libertyroundtable.org/projects/freemelissa/
    >Meet our new friend Melissa. She's a fairly ordinary 'girl next door' who 
    >has a day job and does web design. She also has a healthy respect for 
    >human beauty and is completely unashamed of her body. She has combined the 
    >two and built a web site that features, among other things, nude pictures 
    >of her, some in what appear to be fairly public places ... and found that 
    >she really likes the feeling this gives her. She compares it to a natural 
    >high.
    >
    >For our part, we are not exhibitionists, but do believe that anything that 
    >de-mystifies sex, shows that good clean fun and healthy bodies are not 
    >'dirty', is a very positive thing. There's no end to the flood of misery 
    >produced by people's twisted ideas about sex, love, and the human body, so 
    >we say: 'Hurray for Melissa's one woman war against benighted puritan 
    >attitudes!' That Melissa's site has a commercial side makes her work no 
    >less valuable -- have not libertarians and objectivists always said that 
    >freedom is so valuable that there ought to be a way to promote it at a 
    >profit? We agree with Melissa; she has nothing to be ashamed of, not her 
    >body, not her pictures, not her profit.
    >
    >Unfortunately the police don't see it our way -- or perhaps they do, but 
    >have their hands tied by blue-nosed laws that should be stricken from the 
    >books. Whatever the reason, Melissa has been targeted and ticketed for 
    >"public nudity" and faces a $500 fine and possible jail time of up to six 
    >months.
    
    >Even if everything Melissa is accused of is true (and with photoshop being 
    >what it is these days, no one can really claim that pictures on a web site 
    >prove anything anymore), it would not be as though she had flashed anyone, 
    >nor subjected anyone who did not want to see it to the sight of her body. 
    >Her pictures were taken in a discrete environment of consent, and viewed 
    >online by people who chose to see them. The only crimes committed are 
    >those of the authorities who are willing to apply the full force of law to 
    >a woman who has hurt no one. Make no mistake, for daring to enjoy her 
    >freedom, her self, and sharing that fun, Melissa is to be arraigned on 
    >January 29, and could soon be the victim of legalized theft and enslavement.
    >
    >We should also say, lest anyone think we are trying to mislead freedom 
    >activists (or Melissa herself), that she never claimed to be a 
    >libertarian. In fact, while she does believe her web site has artistic 
    >merit and should be protected by the First Amendment, and the playful 
    >banter on the site is an unabashed sales pitch ('unabashed' just seems to 
    >go hand in hand with Melissa), she says it's really all about having fun. 
    >She would do it anyway, even if there was no money to be made, and she 
    >says she's willing to spend every last penny she gets from the site 
    >fighting for her freedom to express herself (and everyone else's freedom too).
    >
    >So, how can you help?
    >
    >Well, Melissa says that she wants to fight this "all the way" and has no 
    >intention of taking any plea bargains. So, of course, there're legal 
    >expenses. But rather than asking people to contribute to a legal defense 
    >fund, she asks folks who want to help to "sign up" for her web site 
    >(register as paying subscribers to gain access to the full content of the 
    >site). Even if you don't want to see pictures of Melissa, this will help 
    >her, financially, of course, but also to show that many people approve of 
    >what she's doing -- or, at least, disapprove of what the state is doing to 
    >her. It seems to me that there is no better way to show appreciation for 
    >an artist than to pay for her work; it has a better, cleaner feel than 
    >straight charity and allows her to be able to give some value in return 
    >for the help.
    
    _______________________________________________
    Politech mailing list
    Archived at http://www.politechbot.com/
    Moderated by Declan McCullagh (http://www.mccullagh.org/)
    



    This archive was generated by hypermail 2b30 : Mon Jan 26 2004 - 21:24:13 PST