On Thu, Jul 11, 2002 at 07:11:26AM -0500, Seymour, Keith wrote: > While I don't agree with Threatening letters from large corp reps it's > better than what it could be. Maybe you should all take a minute and let > your congressman know how you feel on this issue: > I wholeheartedly agree. There's another potential measure that could be taken, to "muddy the waters", as it were. Some of you may be familiar with the efforts the RIAA has taken to seed the various P2P networks with files designed to deceive the potential downloader into believing they are full, copyrighted works (see http://slashdot.org/articles/02/07/06/0229236.shtml?tid=141 http://www.zeropaid.com/news/articles/auto/07052002e.php ). One could imagine a scenario in which P2P users begin distributing "fake" files named provocatively, such that one is led to believe they contain full copyrighted movie or television works, but in reality contain static, or perhaps more appropriately someone reading the text of the decision in the Betamax case. The technique that the RIAA employs via Overpeer is useful to them, because they know exactly what files were seeded, and exactly how they were named. Rather than attempt to plug the sieve, they've attempted to poison the well. If the P2P community were to turn the tables on a group like the MPAA by employing similar tactics, the group may find it difficult to pursue cases based on a list of provocative filenames. It's not difficult to imagine these tactics, on both sides, being the first blows in an escalating arms race of content obfuscation. Eventually, we may see the P2P community availing themselves of other tactics used by the media conglomerates, such as embedding weak encryption into the files being shared, so that only those with the appropriate key can view or listen to the files. This key could be kept suitably "secret", distributed only to the group of people "authorized" to have the key, in much the same way the CSS scheme works today. It would be interesting to see if the DMCA could be applied from either side of the street in such an instance. -- Mark C. Langston markat_private Systems & Network Admin http://www.bitshift.org
This archive was generated by hypermail 2b30 : Thu Jul 11 2002 - 18:35:58 PDT