[ISN] Multi-nation cybercrime pact gets OK

From: InfoSec News (isnat_private)
Date: Mon Jun 25 2001 - 02:47:07 PDT

  • Next message: William Knowles: "[ISN] 'Chinaman' dethrones 'Hacker' on cyber-terror hit parade"

    By Robert Lemos
    ZDNet News 
    June 22, 2001 1:25 PM PT
    A committee on crimes for the Council of Europe signed off Friday on
    the final draft of a broad treaty that aims to help countries fight
    cybercrime, but which critics say sacrifices privacy protections.
    When ratified by the council's leadership and signed by individual
    countries, the Convention on Cyber-Crime will bind countries to
    creating a minimum set of laws to deal with high-tech crimes,
    including unauthorized access to a network, data interference,
    computer-related fraud and forgery, child pornography, and digital
    copyright infringement.
    The convention--which reached its 27th draft before being
    approved--also has provisions that will ensure surveillance powers for
    governments and bind nations to helping each other gather evidence and
    enforce laws.
    However, the new international powers will come at the expense of
    protections for citizens against government abuse, said James X.
    Dempsey, deputy director of the tech-policy think tank Center for
    Democracy and Technology in Washington, D.C.
    "The treaty's framers started in the wrong place," he said. "For the
    first nineteen drafts, they kept it essentially a law-enforcement
    treaty. Only in the end did the privacy issues get attention, and they
    never got the attention they deserved."
    The Council of Europe--founded in 1949 and based in Strasbourg,
    France--groups together 43 European countries. If the Convention on
    Cyber-Crime is approved, the United States--along with others that
    have observer status within the Council (Japan, Canada, Mexico and the
    Vatican)--will be allowed to sign on.
    The treaty "addresses an important problem: the difficulties law
    enforcement has in pursing criminals across national borders,
    something that is common in Internet crime," said Patricia Bellia,
    assistant professor at Notre Dame Law School.
    Bellia, formerly an attorney with the U.S. Department of Justice and
    an expert in the jurisdictional problems in prosecuting Internet
    crimes, thought that the privacy problems with the treaty have been
    "The convention is not designed to undermine privacy protection," she
    said. "It keeps existing privacy protections. For example, if the
    United States signed the treaty, it couldn't do anything to undermine
    the Fourth Amendment." The Fourth Amendment to the Constitution is
    generally cited in court cases as protecting U.S. citizens' right to
    Several officials from the DOJ have been advising the European
    Committee on Crime Problems--the group that created the treaty--during
    the draft process. The DOJ itself did not respond immediately to
    requests for comment.
    Although the United States has a foundation for defending privacy, the
    treaty will not force other countries--whose citizens may not enjoy
    constitutional privacy protections--to adopt laws to guard their
    citizens' privacy.
    Last month, the European Committee on Crime Problems bowed to pressure
    from international rights groups and included some provisions in the
    treaty to limit surveillance to criminal investigations and added some
    safeguards to civil liberties.
    But it's still not enough, Dempsey said.
    "Unfortunately, it remains a fundamentally imbalanced document," he
    said. "While the privacy issues received somewhat more attention in
    the final stages of the process, the treaty does not have the
    specificity needed for meaningful privacy protection in the face of
    the increasing surveillance power of this new technology."
    The final draft of the convention will be posted to the Council of
    Europe Web site June 29.
    ISN is hosted by SecurityFocus.com
    To unsubscribe email isn-unsubscribeat_private

    This archive was generated by hypermail 2b30 : Mon Jun 25 2001 - 03:38:46 PDT