Sheesh! This reminds me of Harley vs. Honda, PC vs. MAC, Ford vs. Chevy, Blonde vs. Brunette, Helmet vs. bug-in-the-eye, etc... Since opinions are being freely thrown about, I take that as an invitation for mine. Thanks! IMHO, we are truly in computing's infancy now. It's silly, in my mind, to get feathers all ruffled about which OS is "better", when, actually, they are all such a long way from being great. Unix "matured", and I use the term loosely, in a corporate environment where Data was to be protected from damage, whether malicious or accidental. Windows "grew up" from a bunch of propeller-heads sitting around in their basements thinking about what Cool Things they could make their systems do next, with little or no thought about malicious use. Of course these two perspectives are in conflict. And, of course MS is having to come to grips with the issues of security, just as the 'IX's are having to get more "GUI". As always in our capitalistic society, it's either flow with the changing demands of the customers, or get run over. So far, it's working. I work in an MS environment, though I am allowed a couple of rogue Linux machines to play with. I have supported around 300 users for several years, and I think most people would agree that the biggest security problem we have are the users, topmost being management. Passwords handed around, written on sticky notes, etc. The time we did get hit with the Love Bug virus happened because a manager, who also had DA rights, decided that mail seemed slow one day, so he disables Norton AV (sorry Jimmy) on the Exchange server. Two days later we got hit. Likewise, despite strong counsel otherwise, our Web team thought that they could secure the Web servers by playing with file permissions on the server, likewise uninstalling Norton because of the "performance hit". Then Sircam got us. They still think they got hacked by Chinese hackers! My point is, never underestimate human stupidity. The challenge is to find the proper balance of usability vs. security for each particular situation. One size does not fit all. Sometimes a MS-style solution is just fine. (thread truncated for brevity's sake)
This archive was generated by hypermail 2b30 : Sun May 26 2002 - 11:39:52 PDT